Service charges are a recurring source of dispute between leaseholders and freeholders or managing agents. Where service charges are excessive, unreasonably incurred, or not properly accounted for, leaseholders have legal routes available to challenge them. Understanding those routes and when to use them can lead to significant savings.
What service charges cover
Service charges are amounts payable by leaseholders towards the cost of managing and maintaining the building and any common parts. They typically cover items such as cleaning and maintenance of communal areas, building insurance, management fees, repairs to the structure and exterior of the building, and in some cases major works such as roof repairs or lift maintenance.
The key legal principle governing service charges is that they must be reasonably incurred. Services must be provided to a reasonable standard, and the charges must be reasonable in amount. Leaseholders are not obliged simply to pay whatever the freeholder or managing agent demands.
The right to challenge service charges
Leaseholders have the right to apply to the First-tier Tribunal, Property Chamber, to challenge the reasonableness of a service charge. This is the specialist body that deals with residential leasehold disputes in England. There is no requirement to have used any internal dispute resolution process before making an application, though some leases include alternative dispute resolution requirements that should be checked first.
The tribunal can determine whether a particular service charge amount is reasonable, whether the services were of an adequate standard, and whether consultation requirements that apply to major works were complied with. Significant consultation failures can result in the leaseholder's liability for major works being capped at a much lower figure.
Our property law barristers can advise on service charge disputes and the tribunal process.
The right to inspect documents
Before challenging a service charge, leaseholders have the right to inspect the accounts and receipts underlying the service charge. This right is set out in the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. Making use of this right is an important first step, as it allows you to understand what you are being charged for and to identify any items that appear unreasonable or unexplained.
If the landlord fails to provide the requested information, this is itself a breach of their legal obligations and can be relevant to any subsequent tribunal proceedings.
Consultation requirements for major works
Where the cost of works or services to be carried out under a long-term agreement will exceed a threshold set out in legislation, the landlord is required to follow a statutory consultation process before the works are commenced. This involves notifying leaseholders, inviting nominations for contractors, and seeking observations before a decision is made.
Where the consultation requirements are not followed, leaseholders may be entitled to limit their contribution to the works to the statutory cap, currently set at a certain amount per leaseholder regardless of the total cost. This can amount to a very significant saving where major building works are involved.
Acting before paying under protest
One practical issue is whether to pay a disputed service charge while a challenge is in progress. Withholding payment carries the risk of being in arrears under the lease, which can have consequences. However, paying under protest preserves the right to challenge. Taking legal advice before deciding whether and how to make payment is sensible where the amounts are significant.
To discuss your next steps with a specialist barrister, reach out to our team today.
Need advice or representation?
Instruct a specialist barrister directly, without a solicitor. Tell us about your matter and we will match you with the right expert.
Need advice or representation?
Instruct a specialist barrister directly, without a solicitor. Tell us about your matter and we will match you with the right expert.
Submit your case →